diff --git a/src/features/account-timeline/index.tsx b/src/features/account-timeline/index.tsx
index 309021107..1d0065035 100644
--- a/src/features/account-timeline/index.tsx
+++ b/src/features/account-timeline/index.tsx
@@ -32,7 +32,7 @@ const AccountTimeline: React.FC<IAccountTimeline> = ({ params, withReplies = fal
   const path = withReplies ? `${account?.id}:with_replies` : account?.id;
   const showPins = settings.account_timeline.shows.pinned && !withReplies;
   const statusIds = useAppSelector(state => getStatusIds(state, { type: `account:${path}`, prefix: 'account_timeline' }));
-  const featuredStatusIds = useAppSelector(state => getStatusIds(state, { type: `account:${account?.id}:pinned`, prefix: 'account_timeline' }));
+  const featuredStatusIds = useAppSelector(state => getStatusIds(state, { type: `account:${account?.id}:with_replies:pinned`, prefix: 'account_timeline' }));
 
   const isBlocked = useAppSelector(state => state.relationships.getIn([account?.id, 'blocked_by']) === true);
   const unavailable = isBlocked && !features.blockersVisible;
diff --git a/src/reducers/timelines.ts b/src/reducers/timelines.ts
index 50f6fd823..e4919fc8d 100644
--- a/src/reducers/timelines.ts
+++ b/src/reducers/timelines.ts
@@ -352,12 +352,12 @@ const timelines = (state: State = initialState, action: AnyAction) => {
       }));
     case PIN_SUCCESS:
       return state.updateIn(
-        [`account:${action.accountId}:pinned`, 'items'],
+        [`account:${action.accountId}:with_replies:pinned`, 'items'],
         ids => ImmutableOrderedSet([action.statusId]).union(ids as ImmutableOrderedSet<string>),
       );
     case UNPIN_SUCCESS:
       return state.updateIn(
-        [`account:${action.accountId}:pinned`, 'items'],
+        [`account:${action.accountId}:with_replies:pinned`, 'items'],
         ids => (ids as ImmutableOrderedSet<string>).delete(action.statusId),
       );
     default: